PawCRYPTID BOARDDocument the weird. Investigate the unknown.New

Other Aquatic · Village of Great Neck, New York · 1898

NY-1898ID case-872060c658Added to map Oct 30, 2026
Creature
Other Aquatic
When
Mar 1898to the month
Where
Village of Great Neck, New Yorkto town level
Reports
1 document1 independent

The account

Samuel Dunlap reports catching a strange monster while fishing at Saddle Rock.

See the source ↓ one document so far, so there is no trail to follow yet

We map claims, not creatures: this is what the sources say, not proof. How a case is built

Details

Creature
Other Aquatic
Where
Village of Great Neck, Town of North Hempstead, Nassau County, New York, 11023, United States
mapped to town level · from the report's own words
When
Mar 1898
Account
Not first-hand (retold or reported by someone else)
Backed by
1 independent source
Added to map
Oct 30, 2026
Case id
case-872060c658

Place lookups use data © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL), via Nominatim. All credits

Source trail (1)

Every link goes to where we found the account. The earliest we found is marked; it is the earliest found, not necessarily the original.

  1. Image 7 of New York evening journal (New York [N.Y.]), March 12, 1898, (LATEST AFTERNOON EDITION)
    Newspaper · 1898-03-12
    Earliest found, not necessarily the original.

Request a correction or removal of this case

Further reading

Books we have not reproduced: borrow them free at archive.org. Listing a book is not an endorsement of its claims.

Discussion (0)

No comments on this case yet.

Sign in to comment.