Mothman reports in New Jersey
1 case, best-documented first. Page 1 of 1.
We map claims, not creatures. A case is what some source says someone saw or heard, with the link to that source. It is not proof that anything was there, and a retelling counts once, not as a second sighting.

Mothman · The Pine Barrens, New Jersey
The narrator reports seeing a large winged creature with red eyes and hearing it flap its wings outside their cabin in the Pine Barrens.